Wednesday, February 09, 2011



We agree with Michael Collins Piper that the Israeli plan is to set Arabs against Arabs.

We disagree with Ralph Shoenman that the majority of Egyptians are starving and that Israeli troops will invade in order to put down the protests in Cairo.

On 7 January 2011, Michael Collins Piper wrote: 'CATASTROPHIC ZIONISM': HOW TURMOIL BENEFITS ISRAEL

Among the points made:

1. In 1982, Oded Yinon, an Israeli journalist with close links to Israel's Foreign Ministry, wrote 'A Strategy for Israel in the 1980s.'

This outlined an Israeli strategy to break up the Arab world.

Arabs were to be set against Arabs.

2. Israeli dissident Israel Shahak said this was designed 'to make ... Israel into a world power'.

3. In Iraq we have seen Arabs set against Arabs.

4. Israel helped set up Hamas in order to set Arabs against Arabs.

5. In 1988, Ralph Schoenman, in his book The Hidden History of Zionism, noted Yinon's intent of 'double-crossing Mubarak'.

Shoenman emphasized that the Yinon paper hoped for 'the downfall and dissolution of Egypt,' despite the 1979 Camp David peace agreement.


Schoenman appears to be a truth seeker and yet while "visiting Iran during the waning days of the Shah's regime" he worked to raise "awareness of atrocities by the U.S.-backed government."

In other words it looks as if he could have been part of the CIA plot to oust the Shah.

Schoenman appears to be very anti-Zionist.

But, there is a theory (How To Spot A Fake Anti Zionist.) that "The Fake Anti Zionist Researchers ... know you are against Zionism so they created disinfo people that tell you the things you want to hear about Zionist crimes.

"Deep cover CIA agent Ralph Schoenman will critique Zionism beautifully, but proceed to attack you if you point out irrefutable hard evidence that the 1969 Moon Mission was a hoax."

Chicago, 1954
There are poor people in Egypt. But, this photo shows Chicago in the USA. Life expectancy in Egypt is 70.1 years, the same as in many parts of the USA.

On 8 February 2011, Iran's Press TV interviewed Ralph Schoenman (Is El-Baradei for the Egyptian people?):

We disagree with most of what Schoenman says in this interview.

Schoenman seems to be a disinformation agent when he writes of Egypt:

A. "over 60% of the population, not 40%, living on less than $2 a day; the total inability of families to receive food..."

This of course is nonsense, intended presumably to prolong the protests.

B. "Meanwhile multiple platoons of warships have left the US for Egypt: the Connecticut National Guard, US warships are en route...

"And at the same time The Israeli General Staff dispatched some of its top spies to the Sinai desert and actually an Israeli spy was caught blowing up the gas pipeline, clearly an attempt to provide a pretext, a provocation, for the entry of not only US troops, but Israeli troops to put down the mass uprising...."

Note the probable disinformation.

If Israeli troops enter the Sinai it will NOT be to put down the uprising in Cairo.

It WILL be to conquer the Sinai.

Friendly smiles at the Mohammed Ali Mosque, Cairo.
Egyptians by elsa11

Some figures (Egypt.):

1. Between 1980 and 2007 Egypt’s Human Development Index (HDI) rose 42%.

2. Egypt’s average annual HDI growth was 10th fastest worldwide and almost double the global average.

3. Between 2005 & 2008 Poverty, as defined by those living under $2/day, fell over 11%

4. Only 16% of the population now live on less than $2 per day.

5. The Gini Index, the international measure of wealth inequality, fell 7% between 1999 & 2007.

6. The share of the poorest 10% in national income rose 5% and the share of richest 10% fell 6% in the same period.

The ratio of the wealth of the richest to the poorest 10% also fell 10%.

School bus - Transport scolaire
Egypt - school bus, by coalvillestation

Egypt has enjoyed economic growth averaging 4%–5% over the past 25 years.

The Egyptian economy was expected to grow at 6.1% in 2010/11. (Egypt - African Economic Outlook)

"Egypt held up well during the first round of the global financial crisis thanks to its reformed banking sector and low integration into global financial markets as a whole." (Egypt - African Economic Outlook)



Anonymous said...

Here is a direct link to the document mentioned by Michael Collins Piper -
A Strategy for Israel in the Nineteen Eighties
by Oded Yinon (with a foreword by, and translated by Israel Shahak)

It is a must read.
(The link comes via Snippet and Snappets)

The Realist Report said...

Great article, once again. I was happy to hear Piper give you a shout out on his podcast February 7th.

It's interesting to note how Egypt has developed under Mubarak. You would never know that, unless you read great articles like yours.

I think it's clear that although there is genuine anger and frustration coming from the Egyptian street, and disillusionment with the corrupt power structure in Egypt, this uprising is going to be used by the Zionists and their puppets in America for their own benefit. Look who they're already positioning as the next leader-- Suleiman, the go-to man for the CIA and Mossad who has extremely close connections to the Americans and Israelis.

Thanks for pointing out that Israel will not be invading the Sinai to put down an uprising; they will be invading to TAKE the Sinai. The turmoil and division of the Arab world fits nicely into the New World Order Zionist agenda.

Stef said...

The link to the line...

"Deep cover CIA agent Ralph Schoenman will critique Zionism beautifully, but proceed to attack you if you point out irrefutable hard evidence that the 1969 Moon Mission was a hoax."

...isn't working for me but it has the whiff of Eric Hufschmidt about it

Personally speaking, attempts to confuse concerns about the behaviour of the Zionist state with questions about the Naza moonshot strike me as being a fairly strong indication of dubious anti-zionism

It takes a special kind of mental gymnastics to acknowledge that someone critiques Zionism 'beautifully', but then state that they are a deep cover zionist agent in the same breathe

So, by the same reasoning, if I am staunchly pro-Zionist but claim that Apollo was a crock I could really be a deep cover anti-zionist?

Site Meter